2 Maya Ceramic Cylinders
Object or Group Name
Maya Ceramic Cylinders
Case Summary
In January 2011, Guatemalan officials notified ICE that Skinner Auctions was offering four Maya ceramic vessels for sale, which they suspected had been stolen and trafficked into the United States.
When questioned by ICE's Homeland Security Investigations unit, the auction house was unable to provide proof of legal export from Guatemala or import into the US. Dr. Charles Golden of the anthropology department at Brandeis University in Boston later determined that of the four suspect artifacts, two ceramic vessels were genuine antiquities of Maya origin from Guatemala. The other two works were determined to be fakes.
The two authentic artifacts were polychrome cylinders from the Maya Classic Period. The smaller vessel depicts three kneeling Maya dignitaries wearing feathered headdresses. The larger cylinder shows warrior deities with bound captives. It is unknown how or when the works left Guatemala. No provenance was given for the smaller cylinder, but the Skinner catalogue listed the provenance of the larger vessel as Robert Stoetzer, a restorer and authenticator of pre-Columbian art.
In February 2012, the Maya cylinders confiscated by HSI were repatriated in a ceremony held at the Guatemalan Embassy in Washington, D.C. These pieces were returned along with six pre-Columbian artifacts seized in a separate action by US Customs in 2009.
When questioned by ICE's Homeland Security Investigations unit, the auction house was unable to provide proof of legal export from Guatemala or import into the US. Dr. Charles Golden of the anthropology department at Brandeis University in Boston later determined that of the four suspect artifacts, two ceramic vessels were genuine antiquities of Maya origin from Guatemala. The other two works were determined to be fakes.
The two authentic artifacts were polychrome cylinders from the Maya Classic Period. The smaller vessel depicts three kneeling Maya dignitaries wearing feathered headdresses. The larger cylinder shows warrior deities with bound captives. It is unknown how or when the works left Guatemala. No provenance was given for the smaller cylinder, but the Skinner catalogue listed the provenance of the larger vessel as Robert Stoetzer, a restorer and authenticator of pre-Columbian art.
In February 2012, the Maya cylinders confiscated by HSI were repatriated in a ceremony held at the Guatemalan Embassy in Washington, D.C. These pieces were returned along with six pre-Columbian artifacts seized in a separate action by US Customs in 2009.
Number of Objects
2
Object Type
Vessel – pots, amphorae, vases, kraters
Culture
Maya
Auction House
Skinner Auctions
Private Collector
Robert Stoetzer
Receiving Country
Guatemala
Sources
Native American & Ethnographic Art | Skinner Auction 2533B
https://web.archive.org/web/20240623180910/https://issuu.com/skinnerinc/docs/2533b
ICE and CBP Return Illegally Exported Cultural Artifacts to Guatemala
https://web.archive.org/web/20120606102620/https://www.ice.gov/news/releases/1202/120224washingtondc.htm
ICE Returns Artifacts to Guatemala
https://web.archive.org/web/20241207152041/https://youtube.com/watch?v=Fg8skYMHS60
MOLA Contributor(s)
Chris Mechelke
Peer Reviewed By
Lisa Duffy-Zeballos
Citation
“2 Maya Ceramic Cylinders,” Museum of Looted Antiquities, accessed October 8, 2026, https://mola.omeka.net/items/show/1197.


